Story 9: Kate, Somerset

School life was always difficult for my daughter, she struggled with separating from me from reception age but it was manageable and understood better in the earlier years.

As school years developed it became much harder, with staff not understanding the impact the anxiety was having on both my daughter and us as a family. By year 6 it became unmanageable.

My daughter’s teacher had no understanding of her anxiety, how it looked, the distress both she and i went through. One day he said ‘I’m sure she’s putting it on for you’.

I had a teaching assistant say to her ‘stop m being so selfish, mum has to go to work’ as she sat trembling in the car.

Eventually she moved to a part time timetable in the hope it would be more manageable which did have some benefits.

Unfortunately transitioning to secondary school was not at all successful. The support in place was not effective, the communication poor and the senco’s relationship with myself wasn’t positive. I felt there was again such poor understanding of SEMH and I could see things breaking down to the point I had to take 6 months off work, my daughter was an emotional wreck who couldn’t cope with leaving my side even at the weekend.

Our house was full of anger/frustration and we were broken as a family. I applied for an ehcp needs assessment that was refused and school said they couldn’t apply as there was insufficient evidence.

Since she stopped attending school (she is still on role) she has very slowly recovered to the point (after a year) she is able to attend Rama, she is horse riding and is able to be independent. She will stay home alone and go out with friends, all of which were unachievable whilst she was being forced into school to‘build her resilience’, a term I really dislike.

My daughter has built her own resilience in areas she finds manageable and this was impossible in the mainstream education system. Rama has shown that she is able to separate from me confidently, she can learn and she can progress. I just wish that this was understood and provided by our LA.

Story 8: Parent, UK

We spent all of infant school concerned as parents about his reading and writing and behaviour.

We were constantly told he was just a boy and would grow out of it and his reading and writing would catch up if he managed to pay attention. In junior school his teacher recognised his behaviour was an expression of lack of confidence.

We’re now unpicking confirmed dyslexia and suspected ADHD and autism.

The infant school teachers, that were confident he was fine and would grow out of it, don’t see the children that don’t grow out of it and the damage to confidence that occurs because it’s not their lack of effort or maturity.

Story 6: Parent, UK

My youngest couldn’t attend college as she wanted, as they wouldn’t support her as an autistic person if she just didn’t GCSE Maths and English.

Story 1: Mum, Somerset

Our school journey started in 2016 and ended in 2022.

From the beginning we were regularly ‘called in’ to see the teacher due to our son being unable to sit still, we also repeatedly reminded them that he started school when he had only just turned four.

The first two years were similar, being ‘called in’ and being told our son was immature and needed to know he was in school to learn and not socialise!  Year 3 teacher was SEN and we had some enlightening talks about ADHD, Dyspraxia and Sensory processing and this sparked an assessment for a referral to a specialist for diagnosis.  There were many delays in this process and then covid school closures put the brakes on.

Year 4 and 5 were pretty good as the teachers listened to my concerns and provided just enough help and support to get my son through each day.  Unfortunately all support was pulled in year 6 which caused my son to spiral and even masking in school was not working for him anymore.  I engaged an external SEN as begging the school to keep supporting my son did not work.

Eventually my son was so unhappy we felt there was no other choice but to de-register.  The relief for us all was incredible, immediate stress reduction.  My son really enjoyed the social side of school even though he was bullied through all the years, the school did not deal with the long term bullying, which has led to my son thinking there is something wrong with him.  However they tried to teach him resilience!  We were told he would never cope with real life if he didnt toughen up!

Upon leaving I requested all the info the school had on us and one document started that I was ‘an overprotective Mum’.  Surely it is my role to support and protect and advocate.  We as a family feel very let down by the current school system, we firmly believe, with the right support, this could have been an amazing environment for our son.

Unfortunately, a year later, my son is still very low on self confidence and self esteem and often refers back to incidents from school.  We just wish we had removed him sooner before events were so traumatic they have changed our son.  But we are working on this, he is now learning in a safe environment and he is so much happier.

Story 3: Mum, Somerset

Diary of Events

2016/17 – Ruth is 7/8 years old. She is a capable expected rate achiever in school but seems a little unhappy and has no interest in reading at home. She is sometimes writing b’s and d’s the wrong way round. She had previously struggled with recognising 3’s and 5’s. I query dyslexia with school. Ruth’s reading comprehension is age 12.75 and I’m told not to worry.

2017/18 – Ruth seems to enjoy school and particularly Maths, but her friendships are struggling. Her friends are different ages and have different interests. Ruth attends a very small school, is one of only 4 children in her year group and the only girl. Ruth asks if we can home educate. I’d love to but I work (at the school!), and there seems to be lots of people who ‘look down’ on home education. Another girl joins Ruth’s year group which she’s thrilled about and is briefly positive. However, friendships continue to struggle as this girl finds similar interests with the others and not Ruth. Summer 2018 I stop working at the school and take up self-employment.

2019 – nothing improves, Ruth is not happy at school. We move Ruth to a middle school to give opportunity for a variety of friendships and experience of a larger school with more facilities, such as science labs, a PE hall, a wood working room, computer rooms etc. Also, with the viewpoint that this would be a good stepping-stone for an even larger intended high school. Everything is once again positive; Ruth settles well and seems to enjoy school for a while. A girl Ruth becomes friendly with, begins to ‘use’ her, is unkind and there’s questionable bullying happening. Ruth is unhappy again but the girl in question moves on to high school, so we hope things will improve.

2020 – the year of COVID…. During lockdowns Ruth goes up to top set. She didn’t enjoy online school lessons (and so I thought maybe home education wasn’t meant to be). She doesn’t seem bothered about her achievement and says she didn’t really try. Ruth breaks her arm on the trampoline. A couple of weeks later her very close Nan passes from terminal illness (fought for approx. 4 years). Ruth attends the funeral, but I am advised to try and ‘keep things normal’ and so she attends school normally even though school itself isn’t normal, we’re in between lockdowns…. The school support hub is excellent, allowing Ruth time out of class when needed. Ruth is diagnosed with hypermobility and struggles with her joints and pain (including knees locking and feeling like they’re going to dislocate). Finally, we gain schools support with hypermobility after they have been doubting Ruth’s ‘effort’ and a PE teacher showed little compassion saying, ‘if you can’t run then jog.’

2021 – the school support hub seems to lack effort with Ruth now and she says she feels like she’s being a nuisance. My worst nightmare unfolds as Ruth begins self-harming and can’t explain to us why, other than it makes her feel better…. We seek support from school as we are concerned of the number of children in her group of ‘friends’ doing the same. We learn she is ‘presenting well’ at school i.e. Doing her work and not showing any signs of being unhappy. We support Ruth best we can but she irregularly self-harms at school on a few occasions. School advises to see the GP which we decide to take a viewpoint on during/after the summer holidays depending how things go. Ruth is very low in mood and quiet all summer despite us getting away and having lots of walks/keeping busy. No self-harming takes place all summer but she’s a completely different girl to the beginning of last year and it’s breaking my heart. She doesn’t often want hugs anymore and tries to shut herself away in her room. Ruth goes back to school in September for her first day in year 8 and typically a kind hearted girl, helps the new year 5’s happily with no problems, but I still am worried. I know my daughter, i know she’s still not right.

The Decision to Home Educate

I attend a webinar that evening on the myths and truths of home education. It reinforces everything that I thought and wanted home education to be. Ruth is keen, so we go for it. It’s the second day of term and first day of home-education/‘de-schooling’, we decide to go out to get some workbooks. The car breaks down, so we take it to the garage (after we assess if it was safe to do so on google – lesson 1!). We have a bit of a walk into town and do our shopping while the car’s being fixed. As we chat and walk, like we often do, she opens-up and tells me more about her friendships and her emotions than she has all summer, all year in fact. It was like the decision to home-educate had lifted an almighty huge weight off her shoulders and she felt like she could finally talk about it all.

Ruth’s headteacher responded to my letter with a call. He was genuinely supportive of our decision and said there’s a space at school for her if ever we change our minds, be that in a week or several months. He finished saying he looks forward to hearing great things about her.

To date, we haven’t set any plans in stone and are still in the process of de-schooling. Ruth can follow her interests and I will be ensuring she receives a more than sufficient education. I’ve learnt where and how I can access GCSE’s when / if we need to. I’ve downloaded ‘year’ appropriate curriculums for possible guidance but for now, she is just enjoying the learning opportunities life gives or she that she feels drawn to.

The beauty of home education is that schooling, or more appropriately, learning, literally happens at any time of the day. Ruth’s enjoying exploring subjects and skills of interest for herself when she’s ready to and in the right mind to. Cooking is a current favourite. Plus, she hasn’t had to put her food creation in a plastic tub in school where it sweats all day and comes home cold and soggy looking like something you wouldn’t even give to the dog…!

Ruth recently asked if she could learn to use my graphics tablet. She ended up spending two and a half hours, on it. Despite offering my help, she learnt how to use it, figured how to use different features to create different effects and then came up with an idea for a project she completed – all by herself. She wanted to do this. She found a flow and stopped only when she was ready. In school, she would’ve had to pack up after a 45-minute lesson and come back this 2 or 3 times more, to get to a finished project. In effect, she completed 3-4 weeks of ICT learning in one session and without the distraction of other students.

Don’t get me wrong, the learning doesn’t always go well. A clay session was soon brought to a halt as Ruth just got frustrated with it. But that’s okay. I think i would have too to be honest – it was awful stuff!!! She gave it a go and it’ll be there if or when she wants to come back to it. There’s no pressure with learning at home and the learning in this instance was, knowing when to stop something and managing emotions.

Why I Wish I’d Done it Sooner

The opportunities for learning are truly endless.

However, the biggest thing for me and my husband in all this, is that home education has helped us to get our daughter back. She is 110% happier and feels close to us once again. The girl that pushed my hugs away once, now wakes up and comes to hug me. We can prioritise her mental health and wellbeing and we feel able to support and guide her through her education in a way that doesn’t make her feel anxious or undervalued. In a way that school unfortunately just weren’t able to.

Ruth is no longer self-harming and feels positive about her future.

I honestly wish I had found out more about the benefits of home-education and spoken to more people about it sooner.

Story 4: Mum, Somerset

As a mother of 3 children aged between 17 and 33, I have experienced our education system for quite a few years!  Sadly, I have also witnessed its decline over the last 15 years to such an extent that it is unfit for its purpose and damaging our children’s prospects and aspirations.

I have Home-Educated my now 17-year-old son since March 2020. It’s been an interesting but necessary journey which has resulted in a much happier and less anxious young man. Harry has always struggled with the school environment due to being borderline ASD. At primary school I found it very hard to get any help for his neurodivergent issues, in fact I was told on many occasions that the school didn’t expect him to do well in any SATS tests or other assessments and seemed to have written him off completely. His confidence was shattered even more when he was never picked for school teams, especially football, which was his absolute passion. It seems such a minor thing but to him it was earth shattering and completely knocked his self-esteem and confidence. I’m not sure his PE teacher ever realised the hurt and damage caused.

His experience at secondary school was not an easy one to witness. I felt the school was just not addressing Harry’s difficulties despite me gently pointing them out. The meetings I had with them were all very positive and I often came away feeling that at last something was going to be done only to find a couple of weeks later nothing extra had been put in place.

I appreciate schools are under so much pressure due to lack of funding and a ridiculous out-dated curriculum. They just do not serve their purpose anymore i.e. preparing our young people for life filled with optimism, compassion and general good mental health. Yes, qualifications are needed in some areas, but they are not the be all and end all of everything.

I believe organisations like RamaLife have got the balance spot on, promoting self-esteem, self-confidence, compassion and addressing and supporting neurodivergence.

I am certainly not anti-school and I appreciate that many children thrive in this environment but what I am most concerned about is the young people that don’t fit into this group, those who are neurodivergent or suffer with their mental health. As the saying goes ‘no size fits all’ and this needs to be addressed as soon as possible before we lose a generation of talented and wonderful young people.